Plagiarism What It is Its Effects and What the Law Has to Say About It
Browse articles:
Auto Beauty Business Culture Dieting DIY Events Fashion Finance Food Freelancing Gardening Health Hobbies Home Internet Jobs Law Local Media Men's Health Mobile Nutrition Parenting Pets Pregnancy Products Psychology Real Estate Relationships Science Seniors Sports Technology Travel Wellness Women's Health
Browse companies:
Automotive Crafts & Gifts Department Stores Electronics Fashion Food & Drink Health & Beauty Home & Garden Online Services Sports & Outdoors Subscription Boxes Toys, Kids & Baby Travel & Events

Plagiarism What It is Its Effects and What the Law Has to Say About It

What plagiarism is and the legal issues of this area

From academia to business, the stealing of ideas is something that is not only a pain but it is illegal, immoral, and should be stopped. Whether or not this is going to happen is another thing altogether. Many people - writers, authors and serious students put a lot of work into what they produce only to run the risk of someone who is unscrupulous stealing the work and then rubbing salt into the wound by passing it off as their own. This is why educational establishments come down hard on someone who is caught doing this. It is only fair that this subject is dealt with and this article aims to do this in no uncertain terms.

What is plagiarism?

Simply put, plagiarism is taking someone's ideas and written work and passing it off as one's own original work even it is paraphrased rather than a verbatim copy. Now, an important distinction has to be made here. Using a small properly-attributed quote, or other correctly-CITED sources does not count as plagiarism. There are different types and levels of plagiarism, each with their own severity of seriousness and punishment. They are as follows (Source: - accessed 04 January 2010):

· Duplicating someone's work without using appropriate marks such as quotation marks and/or accurate referencing including footnotes

· Duplicating someone's words, phrases WITH footnotes and references but no quotation marks

· Paraphrasing someone's work without referencing it properly and / or using footnotes

· Submitting and copying a work where the words are just rearranged even though they have been footnoted

Is it really that serious?

Yes, it is, within the academia and journalism circles. If you are found guilty of plagiarism in a college and/or university, the least you can expect is a severe warning (if it is done unintentionally) up to expulsion and a potential future as college or school dropout. It is seen as a breach of journalistic ethics and any journalist who has been caught plagiarising faces disciplinary action and could lose their job.

The problem at the moment is whether plagiarism falls under the laws that are currently in place. Having done some research, the area is sketchy to say the least. This is because the law makes a distinction between copyright infringement and plagiarism. One of the key things is the copying itself and its consequences. When it comes to plagiarism, the key issue is that the copying is not being acknowledged or not being acknowledged properly which is dishonest. With regard to copyright infringement, the key issues are whether the creation of the new text involved copying of the old text (i.e. copied text) and the extent or amount of the old text was used. Even if someone acknowledges their sources when they are producing their document, a publisher can still successfully sue--especially if there is some economic value in the stuff that was being copied.

Unfortunately in both UK and USA law, there is no outright ban on copying because there is the 'fair use' clause which opens a whole load of legal and literary worms. If you want to know more about this subject, click here. It explains this area in some detail, what this is and how it relates to this area. Taking lumps out of a book and copying it word for word in your document is going to result in copyright infringement. If you have written a 200 page book and 50 pages of that book are straight out of someone else's work, it is plagiarising on a large scale and can result in legal action being taken against you as the intent is to deceive and misrepresent yourself as the author. Even if a few of the words have been changed does not mean that the plagiariser will get away with it (this goes back to the fact that paraphrasing is considered a form of plagiarism.)

Is it possible to plagiarise ideas and concepts?

The simple answer to that is no. In UK law at least, only expression (recording or written) of ideas is protected. The best example of this can be seen in the automobile sector. There are cars out there that have exactly the same shape even though they were made by totally different companies. As a cake maker, you cannot copyright cake shapes or icing techniques or anything like that. If you write about it, then that is another matter. What if someone steals ideas and copies the text from your book? Then you can you can go after them, but only if you can prove it. The burden of proof is heavy so be careful before doing so and SEEK legal advice. What Joss Saunders said in her article Plagiarism and the Law (2007): sums it up succinctly:

"The difference between plagiarism and copyright infringement is illustrated by the judge’s comment “An acknowledgement is an irrelevance from the point of view of infringement of copyright save in limited perhaps statutory defences which are not raised in this case.

So it is clear that an academic who takes the ideas of another, and expresses them in an original way in a new article is not infringing copyright, even if the conduct be thought to be unethical and a plagiarism. That does not mean however that the plagiarism is without legal effect."

Plagiarism is something that is punishable as educational institutions crack down on this area. The fact that copyright infringement can be sometimes be difficult to prove and plagiarising can be more so, should not mean the law should not offer protection (or more protection than it is currently offering). If educational facilities come down hard in this area, then the law should also. To see how one state statute is dealing with this area, click on this link. If there is an agreement that there is to be no plagiarism between two people and people agree to it, then if it happens, there is protection. I know that on websites there is small print covering a myriad of area--but what about plagiarism? If it were me, I would include a clause along the lines of "by clicking here or by using this site, you are agreeing to not plagiarise any of the content and images contained here and anyone who is caught plagiarising the content will be subject to legal action" It is important to be clear and not bury it. Many people, myself included, tend to click on sites without reading the small print, perhaps it is time this changed, and took the time to request wording from our publishers that protects us.

To summarise, plagiarism is not a new problem and is not going away no matter how sophisticated the detective software is. The Internet has brought us access to information and data on a huge scale and along with this, problems when it comes to plagiarism and copyright. Ignorance can no longer be used as an excuse when it comes to this area, whether you are a writer or a legislator. What will the future bring to this area? Hopefully some clarification and some tightening so here's hoping...

Take care and God bless...

Ngozi Nwabineli © 07 January 2010

Need an answer?
Get insightful answers from community-recommended
in Writing & Poetry on Knoji.
Would you recommend this author as an expert in Writing & Poetry?
You have 0 recommendations remaining to grant today.
Comments (14)

A very difficult issue when it comes to copyright on the internet. So many people and sites steal writer's work and republish it, sometimes even changing the writer name to their own. As you say, there are laws in UK and US but when it comes to China and some Indian sites there is literally nothing you can do. I've been the victim of this more than once. An interesting article though and the more people who know the law regarding plagiarism, the better.

You've highlighted many good points and cleared a lot of things up. There are so many people and so much information on the internet that it tends to get repeated quite often, but hopefully it's reprinted with proper authorization and not plagiarized! Great article.

Thank you Bethany, I appreciate your comments and feedback on this. There is still so much to learn about this area but hopefully this will be a start.

Any writer needs to know this. A few of my friends' work was unfortunately plagiarized. I will send them this link, though they did sort it this time. Thx :) Voted up

Thank you Rox B. People do need to know - not only those who plagiarise but also writers so that they know their rights and how to protect them.

In other writing sites that I'm apart of one of my friends plagarized my work citing the exact phrase that I wrote with the exact picture that I uploaded and the sad thing is, the site just removed the duplicated content and didn't even made the person who's done that accountable for what he did. This is a wonderful article. I'm out of votes but i buzzed it up :)

This is a scary thing for me. I don't ever want to be accused for doing something like this. If it's illegal I want no part of it. The comment above about taking her picture also, I don't see how they even got away with that. Very good article and thanks for good information.

Thank you so much AlmaG. So sorry to hear about your experience. Although plagiarizing is on the up, there seems very little in terms of dealing with it. But hopefully the technology and the law will soon catch up. You are so welcome Teresa. I know that there are programs that check for plagiarizing. I don;t know how effective they are but at least they are there.....

Great article and interesting topic. I have seen my articles with other people's names on them. Someone even took one of my videos and named the author as "administrator". I can't help but wonder if they bothered to watch the entire video because the last slide clearly indicates who made the video and that would be me. I decided to take the high road and wrote as a comment: "I am glad you liked my video enough to re-publish it. Would you mind changing the "author" to my name? I thought that was tactful yet I never heard back. Another person took one of my long articles, modified the title slightly, changed the first line only and copied the rest of the article with his name. Now I am not implying that my articles are any better than anyones elses, but I do put a fair amount of work into them and am not too pleased that others feel they can just take them. But, in my opinion, it isn't worth my time and effort to go after them - i just let these situations be. What do other do when they find similar situations?

ur from triond how does one get ones poetry published here pl advise thanks

quite afew out here r from triond there is a lovely poem /artcle on triond about plagiarism and its defination to include inspiration and creativity by A GREAT POET LOVELY HONEY has any one over here read it yet?thanks its an eye catcher article

correct spelling please DEFINITION TYPO WHAT!!!!!!!!!

Hey love love! I have not joined Triond but I am sure if you ask them that they will be able to help. I do not know what their guidelines are because I have not written for them.

love love

thanks i return from nowhere